Has the 5-Year Rule for Rent Determination Been Abolished? Turkish Court of Cassation Ruling (2026)
Ali Cömert · · 4 min read
In short: No, the 5-year rule for rent determination in Turkey has not been abolished. The Court of Cassation's 3rd Civil Chamber ruled on 3 March 2026 (Case 2025/3450 E., Decision 2026/1141 K.) that in a tenancy that has lasted for many years, a new lease signed later does not automatically reset the five-year period if the rent in that new lease was not brought up to market level at the time. Headlines saying "even with a new lease, you don't have to wait five years" go beyond what the ruling says.
This article is general information, not legal advice. For your specific lease dispute, consult an attorney.
What is the 5-year rule in rent determination?
For residential and roofed commercial leases, the main legal basis for setting rent is Article 344 of the Turkish Code of Obligations. During the first five-year period, rent increases are limited by the change in the twelve-month average of the consumer price index (CPI). For leases longer than five years, or renewed after five years, the judge may set a fair ("equitable") rent by weighing the CPI change, the condition of the property and comparable rents together.
The practical question is: if the parties sign a new, later-dated lease during a tenancy that has already lasted many years, does the five-year period start over?
What was the case about?
- The tenant had been using the property continuously since 2005.
- The parties later signed new leases starting on 1 May 2018.
- The landlord said the net monthly rent of TRY 22,310 was far below comparable rents and asked for TRY 39,000 net per month from 1 May 2021.
- The first-instance court did not set the rent equitably because five years had not yet passed since the latest lease; the appeals court upheld this.
- The Court of Cassation's 3rd Civil Chamber reversed the decision unanimously.
What did the Court of Cassation say?
The chamber did not consider it enough to look only at the date of the latest lease in the file and asked for two things to be examined:
- The real start of the tenancy: Had the tenancy genuinely continued without interruption since 2005? Did the 2018 document create a new relationship, or merely put the existing one in writing?
- Whether the rent in the renewed lease matched market level: Did the rent agreed in 2018 reflect comparable and market rents at that time?
There are two possible outcomes:
- If the rent matched the market at that time: The period in question is assessed under the lease and index terms. The parties' free, market-based agreement is not ignored.
- If the rent was below market: Even if five years have not passed since the renewal, the time elapsed since the start of the original tenancy is taken into account, and, if the conditions are met, the rent may be set equitably.
What the ruling does not say
- It does not say "a new lease doesn't matter; rent can be raised without waiting five years." The ruling concerns the later renewal of a long-running tenancy.
- A first lease with a genuinely new tenant is not the same as a renewal. Leasing to a completely new tenant in 2025 differs from re-signing in 2018 with a tenant who has lived there since 2005.
- The reversal does not confirm TRY 39,000. The Court reversed for insufficient examination and did not set the rent itself. The new rent will emerge from an expert review after remand.
- "A rent determination lawsuit can be filed at any time" does not mean the requested rent applies from any date. The filing date, any increase clause in the lease and notices affect from which period the new rent applies.
Practical takeaways for landlords
- When renewing a lease, set the rent in line with current comparable market rents and keep supporting records (comparable listings and contracts).
- Keep documents showing when the tenancy started and that it continued uninterrupted (old leases, payment receipts).
- Before filing, clarify with an attorney which group your relationship falls into (new tenancy or renewal).
Practical takeaways for tenants
- Whether the rent in a renewed lease matches market level matters more now. If you have lived in the property for a long time, keep your earlier leases and payment records.
- Do not rely on the assumption that "I signed a new lease, so the five years started over"; ask an attorney about your specific situation.
A note for investors
If you plan an investment based on rental yield, factor in that rent increases may be limited by CPI during the first five years, and that after the fifth year the rent may be updated by reference to comparable rents. To compare rental yield multipliers across districts, see our Ankara analysis page and our district selection guide.
Sources
- Court of Cassation, 3rd Civil Chamber, 2025/3450 E., 2026/1141 K., 3 March 2026 (decision text, PDF, in Turkish)
- Av. Erdem Varol — Can a Rent Determination Lawsuit Be Filed Even if the Lease Is New? (Turkish)
- Biem Hukuk — Has the 5-Year Rule Really Changed? (Turkish)
- Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098, Arts. 344 and 345
Would you like one-on-one advisory on this topic?
Reach out directly for regional analysis, suitable portfolio and the citizenship process.
Request Private AccessMore Articles
Property Tax Second Installment in Turkey: Deadline 30 November 2026
The second property tax installment is payable 1-30 November. The calendar, how to check your debt, late-payment surcharge and what to watch for when buying or selling.
Read MoreNovember 2026 Rent Increase Rate: 31.23% (12-Month CPI Average)
Based on TÜİK's October CPI data released on 3 November 2026, the legal rent increase cap for tenants renewing in November is 31.23%. Here's how it's calculated and what the law says.
Read MoreWhat to Do If Your Home's Photos Are Used in a Listing Without Your Permission
A flat's photos can end up in someone else's listing without the owner's knowledge. Here's how Turkey's EİDS rules, Ministry of Trade enforcement, and what you can do about it.
Read More